Yes, my computer is still broken, but I guess I lied and I just can’t stay away. I’m in the library now so “shhhh!” keep it down! This entry is focused on why Cute seems to be surpassing Berryz. It is highly opinionated, so try not to be offended if you disagree. If you consider a group’s popularity by single sales (and not everyone does) all of Cute’s major singles have outsold all of Berryz singles. Now, Cute only has two singles so far, with the 3rd being released soon, but I would be really really surprised if their 3rd single fails to surpass the sales of their last two.
Let’s look at some possible reasons for this, shall we?
1. Cute is getting better promotion: This may be true. Cute did sing the closing to the Robbie and Kerobbie anime, and two of their members are in the group that sings the next opening. However, at least some of their recent promotional efforts may be due to the fact that they’re newer and less known than the Berryz, and 2/3 Buono members are Berryz. Plus, Berryz still seems to get higher billing at H!P concerts and whatnot (their picture is bigger than Cute’s on the cover of the recent summer concert DVD). Also, Berryz has had more photobooks than Cute.So… i’m not so sure about this one.
2. Cute is getting better songs: I think that this one is a factor. We all know that generally in H!P uptempo songs sell better than ballads. Berryz has been getting a lot of ballads lately, and Cute has more uptempo songs. Personally, I don’t think Sakura Chirari is a very good song, but whatever. It’ll be interesting to see what Berryz next song is, and if it is uptempo, if Cute still outsells them or not.
3. Cute is just, well, cuter: Okay. This is the part where I might offend people, but I’ll have to say that I agree with this assesment, and physical appearance is a major factor in idol popularity. Just for fun, let’s take a girl by girl comparison.
The Boyish looking one: Chinami vs Chisato. I give this one to Chisato. Something about her facial structure is just more appealing to me.
The Lead Singer: Miyabi vs Airi. Miyabi isn’t unattractive… but she can be awkward looking, and Airi has been absolutely adorable from the time she joined h!p. Airi wins.
The Tall One: Yurina vs Erika. This one is a lot closer. Erika hasn’t been the most attractive girl, but recently, she’s gotten a lot prettier. Still, I’ll give this one to Yurina, because she looked really nice in her photobook.
The Tiny One: Mai vs Momoko. Mai is pure Cuteness. Momoko has her own kind of weird cuteness, but if you stood her next to Mai and asked who was Cuter, I think that most people would say Mai.
The One Named ‘Saki’: Captain vs Nakajima. Saki Nakajima is another one who has only gotten cuter as of late. As for Captain… I’ve never thought that she was that pretty really. She kind of has a weird face shape, thick eyebrows, and a weird smile. I’m giving this one to Saki N.
The Pretty One: Maimi vs Risako. By virtue of my nickname for this matchoff, i obviously think that both of these girls are quite pretty. It’s a hard choice, but I think I’d pick Risako, because her prettiness is a bit more unconventional, and I think she might be just a tad more photogenic. Really though, this one could have gone either way.
The Overlooked One: Kanna vs Maasa. I feel a bit bad for both of these girls. I can understand that Kanna is newer, and maybe less popular because of that, but neither of them get very much in the way of screentime or lines at all. Oh well. I think Kanna is waaaay cuter than Maasa, so this one is no contest really.
FINAL SCORE: Berryz-2 Cute-5
4.Timing: I believe this is the most important factor. Allow me to explain. When Berryz debued (early 2004) H!P was, generally, more popular than it is today. It may seem like this would work in their favor, and it did to a certain extent, but they also gained themselves quite a lot of the fans that are col
lectively known as “Wota” which is a major turn-off to the general public. Plus, they were younger than the members of Cute are today. As a result, they became the group of cute little girls with a large following of creepy old men. Cute has only debued recently, in a time when H!P kids in general are gaining in popularity, at an older age, and fresh with a relatively small fan-base. Even though they certainly have some Wota fans, it’s somewhat less creepy because they’re older, and there are less of the fans anyway. Cute has a much better shot than Berryz ever did of appealing to the mainstream population, and I think that they are doing just that. Berryz name is already sort of tarnished by their past and fanbase, but Cute has a chance to break out of that stigma and sell to the general public, and therefore, they are currently outselling Berryz.
Just my opinions. Sorry this was so long, and I hope you enjoyed it.